The Difference Between Elder Suicide and Dying With Dignity: Why Some Older Adults Want to Die

Most of us want to extend our lives for as long as possible. The self-preservation instinct is so strong that we hardly question it. We may wonder why anyone would want to end their lives before their natural end. But with some older adults, wanting to die is not uncommon, whether through suicide or the desire to die with dignity. These two phenomena may seem similar, but there is a nuanced difference between suicide and dying with dignity, as well as the motivations behind each.

 The Difference Between Suicide and Dying with Dignity

Suicide is the deliberate ending of one’s life and typically occurs while one is still judged to have many years of quality life ahead. Dying with dignity[1.“Dying With Dignity,”], in contrast, is refusing medical treatment when faced with a terminal or chronic illness.
Most people have an understanding of what’s involved with suicide. But what does dying with dignity look like? Many times, an older adult will make their wishes for end-of-life care known. But gathering and preparing important documents like advance directives, health care proxies, and wills does not necessarily indicate a desire to commit suicide. In many cases, this is simply evidence of prudent planning for the future. Helping your loved one with this is an appropriate way to address the issue of dying with dignity.

Why Do Older Adults Want to Die with Dignity?

Here are just a few reasons older adults prefer to die with dignity, even though their lives could potentially be extended:

They suffer from a terminal illness. Many older adults don’t see the point in prolonging a life that will only spiral downward. They want their friends and loved ones to remember them as they were during the best years of their lives.

They fear pain. Terminal illness often comes with pain. With no feasible option for relief until the patient expires, some older adults don’t want to prolong their suffering.

They fear a loss of dignity. Feeding tubes, breathing tubes, and having strangers toilet you  these are all possible scenarios with a terminal illness. Understandably, many people don’t want to go through this.

They want to make their own choices. Choosing how to live one’s life is at the fundamental core of a person’s independence. This includes how to die as well — when, where, under what circumstances, by what method, and who will be there. Just as older adults want to have autonomy in life, most want to retain it until the end.

They are at peace. It may sound strange to their younger counterparts, but the truth is, many older adults are more accepting of death and feel a sense of peace about the end of life.

Why Do Older Adults Commit Suicide?

There are also many reasons that older adults wish to prematurely end their lives. They include the following:

Depression. Depression is the chief cause of suicide in older adults.[2.“Elderly suicide,”] Getting older can be a difficult process as close friends and family that you once knew pass away, and the difficulty of the aging process should not be discounted when considering depression in older adults.

Isolation/loneliness. These factors are both strong contributors to depression, and older adults are more likely to experience them than the general population.

Feeling like a burden. Many older adults are in the care of their family, with no outside help. If they see their loved ones struggling, and the toll it takes on their own health, work, and relationships, older adults may feel guilty.

Loss of meaning. It’s also common for older adults to feel “useless” during retirement. After working for decades, many struggle with just relaxing and enjoying their free time. They feel the need to contribute to society in a meaningful way but are unsure or unable to achieve this goal.

You’ve Determined It’s Suicide. Now What?

So you’ve given the subject a great deal of thought and finally determined that your loved one may be suicidal, or at least at risk. It’s just not a matter of dying with dignity anymore. Now what do you do? In the short term, calling a suicide hotline or 911 is the first step if the danger is imminent.
Following up with your loved one’s physician and getting them counseling services should be considered. Finally, many of the issues older adults face that lead to suicide can be addressed on a daily basis. For instance, having a home health aide is one option. An aide can monitor pain, offer companionship, and provide more independence by helping the older adult remain in their own home.
It’s easy to confuse signs of suicide with the desire to die with dignity, but the difference between the two are crucial. Knowing the signs of each is the first step to taking the right steps to avoid the first, and, in time, accept or even facilitate the latter.
If you are unsure of how to best help an aging loved one, the trained and compassionate staff at the Institute on Aging is here to help you make that decision and gain the best in at-home care for older adults. Contact us to find out more.

Institute on Aging

Institute on Aging

Related Posts


Give our dedicated Client Service Specialists a call. We are ready to help.

Follow Us

Three and a half years ago, Maggie Fang started her journey as an Assessment Specialist in the Support at Home Program at IOA. Her excellent people skills enabled her to manage a caseload of older adults and individuals with disabilities, helping them receive homecare to age in place. Maggie was selected to pioneer the Temporary Respite Caregiver Support program, and we are delighted to have such a skilled and dedicated individual leading our newest program at IOA. Thank you, Maggie, for your exceptional work! 

#SocialWorkMonth #WeAppreciateyou #ThankYou #SupportatHome #CaseManager #SocialWorkerAppreciation
Join us at the Adult Day Program at the Enrichment Center as Caregiver Coach Alex shares with us the incredible support and care provided to participants living with dementia. Clients enjoy various engaging activities, from music therapy to art classes, designed to stimulate their cognitive and physical abilities. The skilled staff at the Enrichment Center also provides caregivers with much-needed support and respite, allowing them to take a break and attend to their needs. If you or someone you know is looking for support in caring for a loved one with dementia, the Adult Day Program at the Enrichment Center in the Presidio is an excellent resource for you! 

Learn more by visiting the link in our bio! 

#DementiaCare #EnrichmentCenter #AdultDayProgram #CaregiverSupport #Presidio #Dementia #Memory #Caregiver
At Insitute on Aging, we are committed to attracting and retaining top talent, and we are incredibly fortunate to have Manuel Martinez on our team. With his extensive expertise in housing and community resources, Manuel has been an invaluable asset to our organization. Recently, he was promoted to the role of Assessment Specialist II in our Adults with Disabilities - Home Delivered Meals program. In addition to managing a caseload, Manuel has demonstrated exceptional leadership skills and has become an expert in program management. We are grateful for Manuel's unwavering commitment to IOA and the community we serve. Thank you, Manuel, for your dedication and passion in making a difference in the lives of others. 
#SocialWorkMonth #IOATeam #TopTalent #CommunitySupport #HomeDeliveredMeals #SupportingAdultsWithDisabilities
In honor of #SocialWorkMonth, we're shining a spotlight on one of our exceptional social workers - Patty Myers! 

Patty has dedicated her career and volunteer efforts to support older adults and adults with disabilities in San Francisco. As the Resident Services Coordinator for Institute on Aging's Support in Independent Living program, Patty wears many hats to ensure that the 120+ residents of Martin Luther Towers Senior Housing can age in place comfortably. Her talent for connecting individuals with resources has enabled her to go above and beyond to ensure accessibility and inclusivity for all. Patty's commitment to her work has been unwavering, and we are grateful to have her on our team at IOA. 

#SeniorCare #SocialWork #SupportingTheElderly #SocialWorker #SocialWork #NationalSocialWorkerMonth #Services #Coordinator #Joinourteam